The Bible, the Apocrypha, the Qur’an, the Book of Mormon
November 23, 2008
How do you know which book of all of the scripture books out there is the true word of God? Is it possible to really know? How do you explain the role/effect of people in forming the different books? Christian answer site,
GodQuestions.org, says:
The question of which (if any) religious text is the true word of God
is of utmost importance. To avoid circular reasoning, the first
question we must ask is: how would we know if God communicated in the
first place? Well, God would have to communicate in a manner that
people could understand, but that also means that people could make up
their own messages and simply claim that they came from God. So, it
seems reasonable to think that if God wanted to authenticate His
communication He would have to verify it in a manner that could not be
duplicated by mere humans - in other words, by miracles. This narrows
the field considerably.
On the Bible:Beyond the evidence for the Bible's correctness (manuscript evidence)
and its historicity (archeological evidence), the most important
evidence is that of its inspiration. The real determination of the
Bible's claim to absolute inspired truth is in its supernatural
evidence, including prophecy. God used prophets to speak and write down
His Word and God uses miracles like fulfilled prophecy to authenticate
His messengers.
For example, in
Genesis 12:7,
God promises that the land of Israel was to be for Abraham and his
descendants. In 1948 Israel was returned back to the Jewish people for
the second time in history. This may not seem so astonishing until you
realize that no nation in the history of the world has been scattered
from its homeland and returned! Israel has done it twice.
The book of
Daniel predicts with accuracy the coming of the four great kingdoms
from Babylon, to Medo-Persia, to Greece, to Rome centuries before some
of those kingdoms came on the scene (a time span of over 1,000 years!)
with details concerning how they would rule and be broken. This
includes the reigns of Alexander the Great and Antiochus Epiphanies.
(read the full article for
more examples of Biblical prophecies that were fulfilled)
On the Qur'an:Now consider the Quran - its author, Muhammad, performed no miracles to
back up his message (even when he was asked to by his followers - Sura
17:91-95; 29:47-51). Only in much later tradition (the Hadith) do any
alleged miracles even show up and these are all quite fanciful (like
Muhammad cutting the moon in half) and have zero reliable testimony to
back them up.
Further, the Quran makes clear historical errors. Muslims
believe the Bible is inspired but with some errors from editing (Sura
2:136 as well as Suras 13, 16, 17, 20, 21, 23, 25). The question they
cannot adequately answer is: "When was the Bible corrupted?" If they
say before 600 A.D. then how can the Quran admonish believers to read
it? If they claim it was after 600 A.D., then they have jumped out of
the frying pan and into the fire, for we have absolutely no doubt as to
the accuracy of biblical manuscripts from at least the 3rd century
forward.
Even if Christianity were false, the Quran still has an
insurmountable problem because it makes judgments against Christians
for believing things that they do not (nor have they ever) believed.
For example, the Quran teaches that Christians believe the Trinity is
the Father, the Mother (Mary), and the Son (Sura 5:73-75, 116), and the
Quran also teaches that Christians believe that God had sex with Mary
to have a son (Suras 2:116; 6:100-101; 10:68; 16:57; 19:35; 23:91;
37:149-151; 43:16-19). If the Quran is really from God, then it should
at least be able to accurately report what Christians believe.
On the Book of Mormon:
Joseph Smith, the author of the Book of Mormon, tried to do some miracles such as prophecy (a test for a true prophet in
Deuteronomy 18:21-22)
but failed several times. He foretold of Christ's second coming in
History of the Church (HC) 2:382. Joseph Smith preached that the coming
of the Lord would be in 56 years (about 1891). The second coming did
not occur in 1891, and the Mormon Church does not claim that it did.
Nor has it occurred since.
He also prophesied that several cities would
be destroyed in Doctrine and Covenants (D&C) 84:114-115. New York,
Albany and Boston were to be destroyed if they rejected the gospel
according to Smith. Joseph Smith himself went to New York, Albany, and
Boston and preached there. These cities did not accept his gospel, yet
they have not been destroyed.
Another famous false prophecy of Joseph
Smith was his "END OF ALL NATIONS" in D&C 87 concerning the
rebellion of South Carolina in the war between the states. The South
was supposed to call on Great Britain for aid, and as a result war
would be poured out upon all nations; slaves would revolt; the
inhabitants of the earth would mourn; famine, plague, earthquake,
thunder, lightning, and a full end of all nations would result. The
South finally did revolt in 1861, but the slaves did not rise up, war
was not poured out upon all nations, there was no worldwide famine,
plague, earthquake, etc., and there was no resulting "end of all
nations."
On the Apocrypha:
The collection of writings that Protestants call the Apocrypha (hidden
writings), Roman Catholics call the deuterocanonical (later or second
canon) books. These books were written between 300 B.C. and 100 A.D.,
the Intertestamental Period between the inspired writings of God's
Prophets in the Old Testament and those of the Apostles and their
contemporaries in the New Testament. These were "infallibly" accepted
into the Bible by the Roman Catholic Church in 1546 at the Council of
Trent.
Now the Apocrypha would be covered under the evidence for the
Bible if these writings were truly inspired - but evidence seems to
indicate that they are not. In the Bible we find prophets of God whose
messages are ratified by miracles or prophecy that comes true, and
whose message is immediately accepted by the people (
Deut 31:26;
Josh. 24:26;
1 Samuel 10:25;
Daniel 9:2;
Col. 4:16;
2 Peter 3:15-16).
What we find in the apocrypha is just the opposite - no apocryphal book
was written by a prophet; in fact one book specifically states that it
is not inspired (
1 Maccabees 9:27)!
None of these books were included in the Hebrew Scriptures.
There is no
ratification of the authors of any apocryphal book. No apocryphal book
is cited as authoritative by later Biblical writers. There is no
fulfilled prophecy in any apocryphal book. Finally, Jesus, who quoted
from every section of Old Testament Scripture, never once quoted from
the apocrypha. Neither did any of His disciples.
The Bible so far outshines every competing source for being God's
revelation that if it is not God's Word, it would seem impossible to
choose among the leftovers. If the Bible is not God's Word, then we
have been left with no clear criteria by which to know what might be.